Skip to content

NEWS

Suno and the Munich ruling: why Eminem’s publisher leans on a German court

On 6 November 2026, Eight Mile Style, the publisher of 269 Eminem compositions, sued Suno in California. Its complaint leans on a judgment from Munich, where a German court found on 31 July that training Suno in the United States was not covered by US fair use.

Lire cet article en français

Facade of the old Munich courthouse, home of the Munich Regional Court I, photographed in May 2007
The Munich courthouse, seat of the Munich Regional Court I and of the Bavarian Ministry of Justice, on 20 May 2007. Photo: Callipides, CC BY-SA 2.0 DE, via Wikimedia Commons, cropped (same licence)

In brief

  • The complaint (case 3:26-cv-13399, Northern District of California) seeks up to $47,747,500 in statutory damages across three claims for 269 works. These are ceilings, not sums owed: nothing has been decided.
  • On 31 July 2026, the Munich Regional Court I ruled for GEMA, Germany’s music collecting society, on six songs: memorising them in Suno’s models is a copy, and the EU text and data mining exception does not cover it.
  • In France, Sacem opted its whole repertoire out of text and data mining in October 2023, so training on its members’ works needs its prior authorisation.

An American lawsuit about Eminem, built partly on a German judgment. That is the odd shape of the case Eight Mile Style filed against Suno on 6 November 2026 (complaint). Eminem himself is not a party.

What the Munich court actually decided

On 31 July 2026, the 42nd civil chamber of the Munich Regional Court I largely upheld the claims of GEMA, Germany’s music collecting society, for six songs, among them “Daddy Cool” and “Forever Young” (court press release, in German). Three points stand out. Memorising the songs in Suno’s v3.5 and v4 models, stored on servers in Germany, counts as reproduction, and the EU text and data mining exception does not cover it (the same exception discussed in the CJEU chatbot case). Suno, not the user, is responsible for outputs prompted only with lyrics, style and title. And for the training done in the United States, the court applied US law and rejected fair use. The judgment was not final when delivered.

Where the two cases differ

The Californian complaint calls GEMA’s case “identical conduct” and seeks up to $47,747,500 for 269 works (complaint, pages 7 and 32 to 35). Munich covered six songs. Statutory ceilings are not damages, and a US judge owes nothing to a German one. Suno, meanwhile, signs licences: France’s Believe agreed in September to put consenting artists’ tracks into Suno’s new models, for payment (Believe).

What is still open for Europe

I found no ruling on Suno from a French court. In France, Sacem, the songwriters’ society, opted its whole repertoire out of data mining in October 2023: training on it needs Sacem’s permission. GEMA welcomed being able to sue in Munich wherever the training takes place (our paraphrase). Whether other EU courts follow is unknown. For the wider rulebook, see the AI Act timeline and our Society & Law section.

Frequently asked questions

Does the Munich ruling against Suno apply outside Germany?

No. It is a first-instance German judgment, not final when delivered, covering six GEMA works. Courts in other EU countries are not bound by it, though the complaint filed in California cites it as an argument.

Can a European court rule on AI training done in the United States?

The Munich court said yes in this case, under a German rule that gives collecting societies a special venue. It then applied US law to the US training and rejected fair use, because the songs reappeared in Suno’s outputs.

Can Suno train on songs managed by Sacem?

Not without permission, according to Sacem. It exercised the opt-out under article L. 122-5-3 of the French intellectual property code for its whole repertoire in October 2023, so AI providers must obtain its prior authorisation and negotiate terms.

Can I register a song made with Suno with Sacem?

Only the human part. Sacem says music generated entirely by an AI tool cannot be registered, while lyrics written by a person can be, even over AI-generated music. The registrant is solely responsible for the declaration.

Share this article

Primary sources

  1. Eight Mile Style, LLC et al. v. Suno, Inc., Complaint (Document 1), case 3:26-cv-13399 — US District Court for the Northern District of California (filing published by CourtListener), published 6 November 2026 · accessed on
  2. Pressemitteilung 16 vom 31.07.2026 : Urteil GEMA gegen SUNO — Landgericht München I (Bavarian Ministry of Justice), published 31 July 2026 · accessed on
  3. Gericht entscheidet pro Musikschaffende : GEMA setzt sich gegen SUNO durch — GEMA, published 31 July 2026 · accessed on
  4. Sacem and AI — Sacem, published 1 May 2025 · accessed on
  5. Believe and Suno announce strategic partnership — Believe, published 8 September 2026 · accessed on

An article by the Rédaction Société & Droit, published under the editorial direction of Bastien Hugon. Editorial method and use of AI

Also read