NEWS
Meta’s €805m camera-roll fine in Italy is not just an Italian matter
On 14 November 2026, Italy’s data protection authority fined Meta €805 million because the Facebook app for Android read users’ photo galleries without specific consent. The rule it applied comes from the EU ePrivacy Directive, which sits outside the GDPR’s one-stop shop.

In brief
- According to the Garante, a Facebook feature switched on by default since 2023 accessed photos, videos and metadata on the phones of about 20 million Android users in Italy.
- Meta has 60 days to switch the feature off by default and ask for separate consent; it disputes the decision and plans to appeal, Les Numériques reported, citing Adnkronos.
- In France, the same rule is Article 82 of the Data Protection Act; the Conseil d’État ruled in 2022 that the CNIL can enforce it against a company based in Ireland.
Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million on 14 November 2026, according to its notice. The case concerns a Facebook for Android feature, available since 2023, that suggests photos and videos from the phone’s camera roll as ideas for posts while the user scrolls.
The headline number is large. The amount is equivalent to about 0.47% of the group’s worldwide turnover, according to the Garante’s notice. The legal basis is the less obvious part. It is not the GDPR. It is the ePrivacy Directive, and that changes who else can act. More on privacy and AI regulation in our Society & Law section.
An Italian fine, at first sight
Read quickly, this is a national story. The decision covers about 20 million Android users in Italy, according to the Garante. The investigation started in July 2025 after a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer association in Bolzano. Meta has 60 days to comply in Italy only.
Meta also tried to move the case to Ireland, where its European head office sits and where the Data Protection Commission leads most GDPR cases against the group. On that reading, a fine in Rome looks like an exception.
Why any EU regulator can act on the same rule
The Garante rejected the transfer to Ireland. The ePrivacy rules “do not provide for the one-stop shop mechanism”, it wrote in the official English version of its notice. The provision applied, Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code, transposes the ePrivacy Directive. It treats the smartphone as part of the user’s private sphere: access to what it stores needs free and informed consent, “regardless of whether data is transmitted or any harm occurs”, according to the Garante.
The findings are specific. A single permission covers the whole app and several features with different needs. It is preceded by a vague notice (“enable other features”). The camera-roll feature was on by default. Once granted in full, the Garante says, the permission lets the app read the entire photo library, usually permanently, without the user or the authority being able to check what is used.
France has the same rule in Article 82 of its Data Protection Act. On 28 January 2022, the Conseil d’État (in French), France’s highest administrative court, ruled in a Google cookie case that the one-stop shop does not apply to access to users’ devices in France, even for cross-border processing. The CNIL, France’s data protection authority, had already used that power against the same group: a €60 million fine on Facebook Ireland over cookie refusal, decided on 31 December 2021 in deliberation SAN-2021-024 (in French), according to the CNIL (in French).
For a marketing team in France that runs its own Android app, the lesson is practical. One blanket photo permission, a generic notice and a feature switched on by default are the three points the Garante listed. The same test would apply to any app under Article 82, not only to Meta.
Where the GDPR still decides
The ePrivacy route covers access to the device. It does not cover what happens to data afterwards. The Garante states that its case did not examine whether the content was used to train AI, which Meta denies. Objecting to the use of public posts for AI training remains a GDPR question; our guide on how to object to AI training on your personal data covers that route. Cross-border data flows are a separate issue too, as in the case of the DeepSeek API and data sent to China.
What is still open
Meta disputes the facts and the amount and intends to appeal, according to Adnkronos as quoted by Les Numériques (in French). The Garante may examine separately a feature launched in 2026 that processes camera-roll content in the cloud. No date has been given. By 16 November 2026, the CNIL had published no announcement on the Facebook feature.
Frequently asked questions
Does the €805 million Meta fine apply outside Italy?
No. The Garante decision of 14 November 2026 covers users in Italy only. The underlying rule exists in every EU country, so another national authority could open its own case, but none had announced one by 16 November 2026.
Why did the Irish Data Protection Commission not handle the case?
Because the Garante applied the ePrivacy Directive, not the GDPR. The ePrivacy regime has no one-stop shop, so each national authority enforces access to devices on its own territory, according to the Garante and, for France, the Conseil d’État.
Did Meta use camera-roll photos to train its AI?
The Italian case did not examine that question, and Meta denies it. The Garante says it may look separately at a feature launched in 2026 that processes camera-roll content in the cloud.
Share this article
Primary sources
- Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro — Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, published 14 November 2026 · accessed on
- Décision n° 449209, Sociétés Google LLC et Google Ireland Limited — Conseil d’État, published 28 January 2022 · accessed on
- Cookies : la CNIL sanctionne Google à hauteur de 150 millions d’euros et Facebook à hauteur de 60 millions d’euros (lettre d’information n° 1) — CNIL, published 6 January 2022 · accessed on
- Délibération n° SAN-2021-024 du 31 décembre 2021 concernant la société Facebook Ireland Limited — CNIL (texte reproduit par LibreJustice), published 31 December 2021 · accessed on
- Facebook fouillait la galerie photo de 20 millions de smartphones : voici comment couper cette option chez vous — Les Numériques, published 16 November 2026 · accessed on
An article by the Rédaction Société & Droit, published under the editorial direction of Bastien Hugon. Editorial method and use of AI


